Workers' Comp Audit FAQs

Understand how workers' compensation audits work and how pay-as-you-go billing reduces audit surprises. Common audit questions answered by E-COMP.

Frequently asked questions

I have a pay-as-you-go policy. Why do I have an audit?

Pay-as-you-go policies are still subject to audit, like most workers’ comp policies. The difference is that the result is usually smaller, since premium was already based on reported payroll.

Can my audit balance be billed in installments?

Yes. Email audits@goecomp.com to set up a payment plan.

Do I need to send a check for my audit balance?

With Travelers and The Hartford, we auto-debit the account on file and notify you 2 days before. With any other carrier, you'll get an invoice and payment instructions directly from them.

My audit was estimated. What does this mean?

The carrier couldn't reach you for info, so they estimated. Email audits@goecomp.com and we'll get it revised.

I have questions about my audit. Who can I contact?

Email audits@goecomp.com for a response within 1 business day.

What if I don't agree with the findings?

You can dispute them. Common reasons include wrong class codes, payroll that doesn’t match what you reported, or subcontractors charged as uninsured when you have valid certificates. Send the carrier a written explanation with supporting documents (payroll records, job descriptions, contracts, COIs), follow the carrier’s dispute process and deadlines, and pay any undisputed portion on time. Email audits@goecomp.com and we’ll help you dispute it.

Why does my audit show a balance due?

Common reasons: Fixed taxes and fees weren't fully collected when payroll came in low. Employees were reclassified to a different class code. Unreported wages were picked up (contract labor, included officers, lodging value). A Waiver of Subrogation was added mid-term. Your experience modifier changed retroactively. You didn't hit the policy's minimum premium. Mid-term cancellation triggered a short-rate penalty.

Are independent contractors covered by my workers’ comp?

Usually no—your policy typically covers your employees, not true independent contractors who carry their own coverage. States use their own tests to decide who is really an independent contractor, and if a worker is reclassified as an employee at audit, their pay can be added to your premium. That’s why many businesses, especially general contractors, collect certificates of insurance from every sub.

How do subcontractors and COIs affect my workers’ comp audit?

Auditors often ask for certificates of insurance (COIs) showing each sub had workers’ comp during the dates they worked for you. Missing or invalid COIs—or ones that show only general liability—can cause the sub’s labor cost to be added to your auditable payroll. Collect a current COI before each sub starts, and keep them organized by job and date.

How long do I need to keep workers’ comp records?

There is no single retention period for every record and state. A conservative practice is to keep policy, payroll, and claim records for at least five years, but some state or record-specific rules require longer. Retain claim files until the claim is closed and applicable appeal or limitation periods have passed, and follow any legal hold. Confirm the schedule with your state agency or counsel.