The 7 Biggest Mistakes Business Owners Make With Workers' Comp Insurance
Avoid costly workers' comp mistakes, from misclassification and underreported payroll to lapsed coverage and failing to shop at renewal.
Some workers' comp mistakes cost thousands of dollars. Others can lead to lawsuits, stop-work orders, or personal liability. Here are seven common mistakes business owners make and how to avoid them.
Mistake 1: Going Without Coverage When It’s Required
Most states require workers' comp once a business hires its first employee or reaches the state’s threshold. Going without coverage can bring fines, back premiums, personal liability for injuries, stop-work orders, and in some cases criminal penalties. Get coverage before it is required, not after an injury occurs.
Mistake 2: Misclassifying Employees as Independent Contractors
State workers' comp boards and the IRS use tests based on how work is actually performed. If you control how, when, and where the work gets done, the worker may be an employee regardless of the contract label. Misclassification can result in back premiums and penalties. Ask a qualified professional when a worker’s status is unclear.
Mistake 3: Not Comparing Quotes From Multiple Carriers
Different carriers price the same risk differently based on underwriting appetite, state experience, and industry expertise. E-COMP shops 50+ top-rated carriers so business owners can compare available options rather than automatically accepting the first quote.
Mistake 4: Underreporting Payroll to Lower Premium
Every workers' comp policy ends with an audit. Actual payroll is reconciled against the estimate used to begin the policy. Underreporting can lead to a balance due, penalties, cancellation, and loss of coverage availability. Estimate honestly and update payroll when your business changes.
Mistake 5: Letting Your Coverage Lapse
Even a one-day gap can leave you uninsured for injuries during that period. A lapse can also affect state compliance and future underwriting. Have replacement coverage in place before canceling an existing policy and use automatic payments or renewal reminders when available.
Mistake 6: Failing to Build a Return-to-Work Program
When an injured employee can safely return to light or modified duty, claim costs may drop and recovery can improve. Document light-duty roles, build a relationship with an occupational health provider, and train supervisors to support a safe transitional return.
Mistake 7: Auto-Renewing Without Shopping the Market
Business operations, carrier pricing, and market conditions change every year. Get an alternative quote before renewal or ask E-COMP to remarket your coverage. A short annual review can reveal better pricing, improved terms, or coverage gaps.
Frequently Asked Questions
What happens if I do not have workers' comp and an employee gets hurt?
You may be personally liable for medical bills, lost wages, and damages. You can also face state fines, stop-work orders, and other penalties.
How often should I shop my workers' comp coverage?
Review coverage every year at renewal. Your business, claims history, and the insurance market may have changed.
Can I be audited if I underreport payroll?
Yes. The policy audit reconciles actual payroll against reported payroll. Underreported payroll can create a balance due and additional penalties.